[This post was inspired in part by a wonderful keynote Emily Chamlee-Wright gave over the weekend as well as her wonderful concept of “the great forgetting.”]
Since one of the radically moderate virtues is humility, I’ll admit I was wrong.
Trump is way more dangerous than I thought he would be. I misjudged his motives, misunderstood his intentions, and underestimated the depth of his selfishness. After watching his first term, I thought I had him largely figured out: egotistical and uninterested in governance, but maybe not completely pathological. I was wrong.
What makes him uniquely dangerous is the damage he is doing to the institutions
- in many ways conservative institutions -
that made the balance between liberalism and democracy possible.
While I have serious concerns about specific policy areas, the bulk of my concerns are in areas I would have thought to find alliances among traditional conservatives.
And this is where the current GOP derangement is mind-boggling, at least to someone who has spent a lot of time studying conservative thought.
What makes Trump uniquely dangerous is not necessarily any particular policy position. There are even (maybe) a few policy areas I might agree with Trump on if his overall approach wasn’t so vicious.
What makes him uniquely dangerous is the damage he is doing to the institutions - in many ways conservative institutions - that made the balance between liberalism and democracy possible.
Ironically, many of the institutions that Trump is systematically destroying are institutions that progressives have critiqued over the years as threats to progress. There’s a strange, perverse way in which Trump’s right-wing populism meets left-wing institutional skepticism at the back of the political horseshoe.
The Great Conservative Flip on Process vs. Outcomes
For decades, one of the things progressives complained about regarding conservatives was their obsession with procedure. Conservatives cared about process, often more than outcomes.
You see this in everything from the focus on rule of law to market processes. The argument, laid out perhaps most clearly in Thomas Sowell’s A Conflict of Visions, was that the conservative mindset values process over results, constraint over power. If decentralized processes like trial by jury or emergent market forces or free elections lead to less-than-optimal outcomes occasionally, that’s fine, because the process itself matters more than any single concrete outcome. Impartial processes shield people from arbitrary power, create predictability, allow for freedom (with guardrails), generate respect for democratic outcomes and protect independent institutions.
These processes, often grown over decades or centuries of tradition, trial-and-error, and tacit knowledge, conservatives once argued, are better at ruling than any one person could be. Rule of law and not of man was the root of principled conservative thought.
No more!
We’re watching - in real time, across post after post on Truth Social and in the halls of the White House - a complete inversion. We now have a right-wing pseudo-populist president openly declaring that raw power matters more than process, that he’ll do whatever he wants to get the results he wants, and that institutions and procedures are obstacles to be demolished instead of guardrails to be respected.
And conservatives—the people who spent decades defending procedural integrity—have almost entirely capitulated.
Trump’s Dangerousness Has (Almost) Nothing to do with Policy Priorities
What interests me the most about this (when I’m not deeply depressed about it) is that the major criticisms of the Trump administration are - or would be at any other time - deeply bipartisan. They have nothing to do with policy disagreements or ideological differences. They have everything to do with the foundations of liberal democracy, broadly understood. And until recently, they would have been widely shared within the GOP and many Republican voters.
While there are a lot of things I could focus on, here’s a run down of just the ones I’ve seen this week:
1. Attacks on Rule of Law and Checks and Balances
Some of this isn’t new. Trump started attacks on rule of law almost immediately: The hollowing out of the judiciary. The replacement of independent attorneys general with loyalists. The purging of career civil servants in the Justice Department who might provide any check on executive power. Thinly veiled (if that) threats to encourage violence against judges who attempt to check his power.
And now, this week Trump is demanding that the Justice Department reimburse him $230 million for his legal cases—despite his family growing astronomically wealthier through conflicts of interest, crypto schemes, and using the presidency to wheel and deal.
This isn’t normal political corruption. This is systematic destruction of the separation of powers that prevents any single person or faction from wielding unchecked authority.
2. Attacks on Civil Society Institutions
Political scientists have identified one of the clearest warning signs of authoritarianism as the hollowing out of civil society institutions—the organizations and associations that exist independent of state power.
The good news is that America has deep civil society institutions. Universities, independent media, nonprofit organizations, professional associations, religious institutions run deep throughout the American landscape and psyche. And we’re seeing genuine resistance, as a growing number of campuses reject Trump’s recent attempt at a higher education compact.
The bad news is that we’re less than a year in.
Trump is systematically attacking not only universities, but the press, nonprofits, and professional organizations. He peddles conspiracy theories (like his attacks on George Soros and the Open Society Foundation) to undermine their legitimacy. He labels journalists, professors, lawyers, and judges as “enemies” and “woke DEI grifters.”
These are textbook authoritarian tactics. And conservatives—who used to champion civil society as the “third way” between government overreach and market self-interest—are either silent or actively cheering him on.
3. Undermining Shared Epistemological Foundations
Maybe even more concerning (I still can’t decide) is Trump’s enthusiastic use of misinformation, his deployment of AI to create and amplify conspiracy theories, and his systematic undermining of data and science—these aren’t just annoying political tactics. They’re attacks on shared reality itself.
The takeover and gutting of the National Institutes of Health. The firing of data scientists and epidemiologists. The elimination of people who track diseases and other crucial public information. The use of AI deepfakes to ridicule opponents and confuse voters.
The goal is to systematically destroy the epistemological foundation that liberal democracy relies on. Not just for voting, but for market decisions and for long-term decisions about resource allocation. Researchers across the political spectrum rely on government data to do a range of important work from assessing the effectiveness of public policies to fueling research on disease.
Without that shared foundation, we can’t assess problems, can’t solve them, can’t even agree on what’s true. We’re destroying the very possibility of evidence-based governance.
Trump’s “Truth Social” platform itself is Trump’s attempt to convince us that truth is whatever the powerful tell us it is.
4. Undermining Respect for Elections
We had Lee Drutman on our podcast a few weeks back and he said something that stuck with me: the main thing liberal democracies have going for them, at least on the democratic side, is the belief that election outcomes are reasonably fair.
What the average person often misunderstands about government is how much of it runs on norms and trust. Liberal democracies are peaceful, insofar as they are, because people can generally trust the government to do what they think is right. Once you run out of norms and trust in the outcomes of a range of government processes, all that’s left is fear and force.
It’s true that our electoral system wasn’t perfect before. We already had gerrymandering, broken primaries, and the need for a much larger conversation about a range of reforms. But Trump’s willingness to openly manipulate electoral outcomes, to be brazenly honest about rigging the game is qualitatively different. And his push for increased gerrymandering specifically to manufacture House majorities crosses a line from “system needing reform” to “systematic destruction of democratic legitimacy.”
5. Violent Rhetoric and Dehumanization of Citizens
This isn’t about “civility” in some milquetoast sense. I’m not arguing that Rome is burning and we should worry about being polite.
Trump’s attacks on civility are deeply dangerous because he intentionally weaponizes human nature and he does so in ways that are hard to undo.
Trump actively amps up violent rhetoric. He weaponizes tribalism. He uses social media to humiliate not just political opponents but ordinary citizens. He attacks public figures, civil society leaders, and average Americans who disagree with him. He intentionally manipulates and stokes toxic polarization.
Just this week, the President of the United States posted an AI generated video of himself on an airplane dropping feces on No Kings protesters.
Again, this is the President of the United States.
The Conservative Betrayal
Here’s my plea to conservative friends: You would never, ever have stood for a fraction of this from a Democratic president. A tenth of this behavior would have had you raising the alarm about corruption, incivility, the desecration of Christian values and of our Founding Fathers rolling over in their graves (particularly Madison).
Yet here we have a president who openly flouts every value of the founding - rule of law, free and fair elections, strong civil society institutions, the list goes on.
I find myself in some bizarre political wormhole where I’m grateful Marjorie Taylor Greene exists because at least someone on the right is occasionally pushing back.
As I’ve argued before, the GOP might get a couple policy wins out of this at the end of the day. Maybe they’ll own the woke libs for a bit.
But what still boggles my mind from the perspective of pure GOP self-interest is that the cost to conservative principles is already catastrophic. While they GOP is adding up whatever minimal policy/culture wars gains they’ll make they’re completely oblivious to the sink hole opening at their feet.
It amazes me that the party that once stood - at least in theory - for institutions, for rule of law, for process and procedure, has completely capitulated its entire value structure to a narcissistic authoritarian and has done so in exchange for a few crumbs of symbolic internet troll victories.
What Radical Moderation Means in This Moment
There’s a broader danger here too. When I use the term “radical moderation,” I mean radical. And in this moment, being radically moderate means having an absolute responsibility to call out the serious dangers growing on the right.
This isn’t “both sides” thinking. I can point to the places the left went off the rails while still recognizing that what is happening now is different both qualitatively and quantitatively from anything that came before.
More to the point, there’s a difference between normal political disagreements—where reasonable people can differ on policy—and systematic attacks on the institutions that make disagreement safe and productive.
Conservatives and progressives and libertarians can disagree about tax rates, healthcare policy, education spending, and immigration quotas. Those are normal political debates that healthy democracies handle through established processes.
But as liberals in the broad tent tradition of American liberalism, there are things we can’t agree to disagree about. We can’t disagree about whether the president should be able to purge independent oversight, whether election results should be respected, whether the judiciary should be independent, whether the press should be free to criticize the government, whether data and science should be systematically undermined to suit political narratives.
These aren’t policy questions. They’re foundational questions about whether we’ll have the kind of system where policy disagreements can be resolved peacefully.
It’s precisely these baseline agreements about limits on government power broadly and executive power narrowly that are being completely undermined.
For people like me, who are sympathetic to progressive aims while sharing conservative concerns about their tactics, we’ve ended up in the worst of all possible spaces: a completely unconstrained government wielding power to serve the powerful.
The previous combinations offered by Democrats and Republicans over the years weren’t ideal, but they weren’t flat out terrifying, at least not most of the time.
What I Hope For
In a lot of ways I’m still optimistic. I’m heartened that the resistance is growing and I’m generally optimistic, as my friend Andrew Cohen put it recently, that this is the last gasp of authoritarianism working itself out and that we’ll emerge from this freer and more committed to liberal democratic principles than ever before.
I’m less optimistic but still hopeful there are people in the GOP willing to start questioning these tactics. I know there are conservatives who remember what conservatism actually means—respect for institutions, suspicion of concentrated power, defense of norms and procedures, commitment to virtue and character.
I hope they can start convincing conservative leadership to recognize that they’re not just betraying conservative principles. They’re destroying the very foundations that allow anyone—progressive, libertarian, or conservative—to govern in a principled way.
The question every American faces right now isn’t whether you agree with specific Trump policies. It’s whether you value the system that makes policy disagreements resolvable without violence.
We increasingly live in a country where that’s not possible because:
Elections are manipulated and their results treated as illegitimate
The judiciary serves the president rather than the Constitution
The press is threatened into submission
Universities are gutted for insufficient loyalty
Data and science are systematically being destroyed to serve political narratives
Civil society institutions are branded as enemies
Citizens who protest are dehumanized and threatened
More of us need to stop worrying about specific policy disagreements or the gutting of the White House East Wing. To a certain degree, those things are intentional distractions.
What matters most is where we can and should be building bipartisan agreement among citizens.
But that optimistic read requires something from all of us: a willingness to prioritize institutional integrity over partisan advantage. To recognize that today’s policy wins aren’t worth tomorrow’s authoritarian decay. To build bipartisan coalitions around the foundations that make pluralism possible—even when that means defending institutions we’ve critiqued, protecting people we disagree with, and insisting on procedures that sometimes constrain our preferred outcomes.
If enough of us can do that—if conservatives especially can remember what they once stood for—maybe we emerge from this stronger, with liberal democracy’s value clearer than ever.
But that’s not guaranteed.
It depends on choices we make right now, while there’s still time to choose.
Your Turn
I’d love to hear your thoughts! Where do you see the most hope? How can we get people to accept that short-term policy wins can’t justify long-term institutional erosion? Is there a way out I don’t see? Let me know in the comments! And please, as always, if you like what you read share and subscribe. This Substack is very much a labor of love. The most meaningful thing you can do is share it with a friend (or a few!).



Lauren, thank you so much for this. I feel like I'm totally in the same boat as you. As a traditional libertarian Reagan republican, I'm utterly shocked by MAGA. And, like you, I feel like I'm now radically in the middle. Anyway, let's both keep fighting the good fight!
I will never understand how supposedly intelligent people could possibly think Trump would be anything but exactly the way he is right now in a second term. His former chief of staff called him a fascist. Another former cabinet member and college professor called him an idiot. He tried to overturn the last election. He’s a convicted felon. He’s an adjudicated rapist. He instigated an attack on the Capitol. He wanted to shoot protesters in the legs. It’s been clear from the get-go that he’s Putin’s patsy. And then to top it off SCOTUS gave him full immunity as prez. What in all of that told you he’d be any different than he is? I mean come on.