Thank you so much Lauren for reposting and the comments by Lori too. I shared with my daughters and wife with the comment that I am still at my age learning the skills you describe Your airplane ride has happened so often to me and I can’t say I have been as sanguine as you. Only feeble excuse perhaps is that I can’t simply fall asleep on a long flight. So I’d be awake the whole time. So your essay prompts me once more to chill and show compassion.
I know this isn’t what Lauren had in mind, but her story brings something else to mind that bugs me. Why in those situations do my fellow travelers or shoppers or whatever seem to commiserate with me and not with the miserable child or with the mother?
I am more and more aware of all the people, disproportionately women, in that group disproportionately mothers, in that group disproportionately poor, and certainly disproportionately women of color who are always apologizing for the inconvenience or discomfort they have been made to believe they are causing me?
Sometimes I’m not even sure what they are apologizing for. They seem to have been made to believe that I deserve some kind of peace they don’t have.
I don’t think it’s rational to expect peace in the circumstances at hand.
My tool kit seems to involve a clear eyed look at the world we’ve created to some extent and managing expectations in that context. Knowing what’s none of my business helps.
And I’ve developed a skill that generations of old white southern women have made into an art form. I can tell someone to go to hell, just how fast I want them to get there and how hot I want the fires to burn with a smile on my face and the older guy who assures me I have earned some kind of place in heaven for putting up with a mother and a toddler won’t even realize I’ve done it until he is at home in bed reflecting on the day.
Of late I have been offering to teach classes in that to all my young female colleagues who are asked to be civil with others who expect them to “manage” career, family and civic life with an insufficient set of tools or amount of time.
This is beautifully said, Lori. I completely agree. My sympathy was entirely with the mother in this situation and it struck me as odd how many of my fellow travelers saw her not as a fellow sufferer but as somehow responsible for the chaos, as though people with young children don't need to travel to visit family or move or even go on vacation or whatever she was doing that day.
I sat next to a young couple with a 1 year old on the plane on the flight out here and the father accidentally stepped on a hair clip attached to my bag and broke it. He apologized something like 10 times and I pointed out that (A) he was trying to get into his seat with a squirming one year old when he stepped on my clip and could not have avoided it, (B) the clip itself is almost worthless, and (C) he has two hours of suffering ahead of him while trying to keep a 1 year old happy on a flight. My hair clip should be the last of his concerns, though I appreciated the initial apology because it showed he's a nice person. But the guilt many parents bear for bringing their kids into public spaces is both frustrating and a terrible sign for our future as a society.
"Of late I have been offering to teach classes in that to all my young female colleagues who are asked to be civil with others who expect them to “manage” career, family and civic life with an insufficient set of tools or amount of time." - I would love to sit in on this class. I've developed quite a few of these skills, but still have work to do in this area.
Today I live and work in a very, very rural area. In the largest town which isn’t very big clerks in stores, the ladies at the drive through at the bank, the techs at the hospital, the woman whose cart full of kids is in front of the oatmeal I like, are always apologizing for making me wait.
Look, if I was in a hurry I wouldn’t live in Mitchell County, NC, here in Appalachia. My fellow old …sometimes not so old… white folks who aren’t from around here need to get their head around that.
There is a prereq to the class I offer. Reality-based confidence. The culture has been telling some people they are less than and don’t deserve the grace others take for granted for literally hundreds of years. The first thing my young female colleagues and I talk about is that. Embrace yourself, have confidence in yourself. The ones who have the most trouble are those who have misplaced confidence. When they crash recovery is hard. But for those who have every reason to be confident and aren’t the sky’s the limit.
Thank you so much Lauren for reposting and the comments by Lori too. I shared with my daughters and wife with the comment that I am still at my age learning the skills you describe Your airplane ride has happened so often to me and I can’t say I have been as sanguine as you. Only feeble excuse perhaps is that I can’t simply fall asleep on a long flight. So I’d be awake the whole time. So your essay prompts me once more to chill and show compassion.
I know this isn’t what Lauren had in mind, but her story brings something else to mind that bugs me. Why in those situations do my fellow travelers or shoppers or whatever seem to commiserate with me and not with the miserable child or with the mother?
I am more and more aware of all the people, disproportionately women, in that group disproportionately mothers, in that group disproportionately poor, and certainly disproportionately women of color who are always apologizing for the inconvenience or discomfort they have been made to believe they are causing me?
Sometimes I’m not even sure what they are apologizing for. They seem to have been made to believe that I deserve some kind of peace they don’t have.
I don’t think it’s rational to expect peace in the circumstances at hand.
My tool kit seems to involve a clear eyed look at the world we’ve created to some extent and managing expectations in that context. Knowing what’s none of my business helps.
And I’ve developed a skill that generations of old white southern women have made into an art form. I can tell someone to go to hell, just how fast I want them to get there and how hot I want the fires to burn with a smile on my face and the older guy who assures me I have earned some kind of place in heaven for putting up with a mother and a toddler won’t even realize I’ve done it until he is at home in bed reflecting on the day.
Of late I have been offering to teach classes in that to all my young female colleagues who are asked to be civil with others who expect them to “manage” career, family and civic life with an insufficient set of tools or amount of time.
This is beautifully said, Lori. I completely agree. My sympathy was entirely with the mother in this situation and it struck me as odd how many of my fellow travelers saw her not as a fellow sufferer but as somehow responsible for the chaos, as though people with young children don't need to travel to visit family or move or even go on vacation or whatever she was doing that day.
I sat next to a young couple with a 1 year old on the plane on the flight out here and the father accidentally stepped on a hair clip attached to my bag and broke it. He apologized something like 10 times and I pointed out that (A) he was trying to get into his seat with a squirming one year old when he stepped on my clip and could not have avoided it, (B) the clip itself is almost worthless, and (C) he has two hours of suffering ahead of him while trying to keep a 1 year old happy on a flight. My hair clip should be the last of his concerns, though I appreciated the initial apology because it showed he's a nice person. But the guilt many parents bear for bringing their kids into public spaces is both frustrating and a terrible sign for our future as a society.
"Of late I have been offering to teach classes in that to all my young female colleagues who are asked to be civil with others who expect them to “manage” career, family and civic life with an insufficient set of tools or amount of time." - I would love to sit in on this class. I've developed quite a few of these skills, but still have work to do in this area.
Today I live and work in a very, very rural area. In the largest town which isn’t very big clerks in stores, the ladies at the drive through at the bank, the techs at the hospital, the woman whose cart full of kids is in front of the oatmeal I like, are always apologizing for making me wait.
Look, if I was in a hurry I wouldn’t live in Mitchell County, NC, here in Appalachia. My fellow old …sometimes not so old… white folks who aren’t from around here need to get their head around that.
There is a prereq to the class I offer. Reality-based confidence. The culture has been telling some people they are less than and don’t deserve the grace others take for granted for literally hundreds of years. The first thing my young female colleagues and I talk about is that. Embrace yourself, have confidence in yourself. The ones who have the most trouble are those who have misplaced confidence. When they crash recovery is hard. But for those who have every reason to be confident and aren’t the sky’s the limit.