A new study in PNAS Nexus, published earlier this summer found that 37% of Americans have ended a relationship over politics. Most of the breakups were with friends. The number has been climbing since 2016, and the breakups produced by the 2024 election reached the 2016 election’s totals in half the time. The researchers, Mertcan Güngör and Peter Ditto at UC Irvine, surveyed almost four thousand people across four datasets and triangulated the answers against a national-election panel. They were measuring something most of us already know: we are losing each other.
This study also undermines a comfortable (and false) binary that some of us lean into, namely that the only options are fight harder or pull away entirely. Either you keep slugging it out with your brother-in-law or you stop returning his calls. Either you wade back into the comment section or you mute everyone who voted differently than you did. Either you keep going to the family dinners and grit your teeth through them or you stop going.
The new finding cuts against the option that feels safest. Güngör and Ditto found that the people who had experienced political breakups were more hostile to their opponents than the people who hadn’t, perceived the other side as more extreme, and were more likely to ascribe selfish motives to ordinary voters on the other side. Walking away does not relieve the polarization. It intensifies it. The phantom in your head gets bigger, not smaller, after you stop talking to the actual person it is supposed to represent.
To be fair, some breakups are right. If someone in your life is cruel to you, or treats your existence as a debate, the healthy move is distance, and no amount of technique fixes that. The study isn’t about those. It’s about the much larger pile of relationships we let go quiet over a vote or a yard sign, where the person was never actually the phantom we replaced them with.
I have been working through this for a talk this week, and the thing that has come into focus for me is that the binary is wrong because both halves of it make the same problem worse. We are not, mostly, fighting about policy. We are fighting with phantoms. When we walk away from the actual person, the phantom is the only one left in the room.
The Argument You Think You’re Having Isn’t the One You’re Having
The political science term for what has happened to us is affective polarization (and I’ve talked about it a lot). It is a precise and useful phrase. We do not disagree more than we used to. On the substantive policy questions that get coded as the Big Issues (abortion, immigration, healthcare, even guns), Americans cluster surprisingly close to the middle, and have for a long time. What has changed dramatically in the last twenty years is how much we hate each other.
We dislike the other side more. We trust them less. We are more willing to believe the worst about them and less willing to spend time with them. Marriage rates across party lines have collapsed. The share of Americans who say they’d be unhappy if their child married someone from the other party has climbed from around 5% in 1960 to roughly half today.
The uncomfortable part is that we are wrong about who they are. Not slightly but substantially. Surveys keep finding the same pattern. Republicans imagine that Democrats are far more progressive than they actually are. Democrats imagine that Republicans are far more reactionary than they actually are. Both sides imagine the other side hates them more than they actually do. More in Common’s 2019 work found that partisans imagine almost twice as many of their opponents hold “extreme” views as actually do. The “perception gap” is one of the most replicable findings in American political psychology right now, and the new Güngör and Ditto paper sharpens that finding to highlight the vicious cycle: people who break up over politics are the ones whose perceptions of the other side are the most distorted. The breakup and the distortion travel together.
(On a side note, Democrats were more likely to have experienced a breakup, and were usually the party who initiated it. The pattern may track something durable about moral foundations, or it may be a reaction to a specific cluster of figures and events since 2016. Güngör and Ditto don’t know yet, and neither do I, though I suspect it has something to do with how progressive-leaning folks talk about harm. I have some posts relating-ish to that here and here.)
This is bad news and good news at once. The bad news is that the country is genuinely sick, and the breakup data gives the sickness interpersonal teeth. The good news is that a meaningful portion of it is a perception problem, which means it has perception solutions. The other side, the actual one with a face and a name and an opinion about your kid’s soccer schedule, is not who you think. The elite voices in the media ecosystem (politicians, pundits, podcasters with monetized outrage cycles) are extreme. Most of the people in your life are not.
Steel-Manning for Curiosity
The most important move in this whole conversation is to make the best version of three positions that don’t usually get steel-manned in their own preferred terms. Pick the one you are least tempted by and read it slowly.
Libertarians. The caricature is that libertarians are selfish, anti-government, and indifferent to other people’s suffering. The good-faith reading is that libertarians see something the rest of us tend to miss. Coercion is real even when it is wrapped in good intentions. The person closest to a problem usually understands it better than the person who is going to write the regulation. Voluntary experiments at the local level often beat top-down plans designed for an averaged-out population that does not actually exist anywhere. The libertarian skepticism is about which institution is best equipped to solve a given problem, which is a different thing from indifference, although the two get conflated all the time.
Conservatives. The caricature is that conservatives are intolerant, stuck in the past, and afraid of change. The good-faith reading is that conservatives see something the rest of us tend to forget. Institutions are slow to build and easy to break. Moral knowledge accumulates in traditions and families and communities in ways that abstract reasoning cannot fully replace. “Let’s tear it all down and start over” is a sentence that historically precedes a great deal of suffering. The conservative position is a bet about how much load-bearing weight the inherited structures are doing, and a worry that we routinely underestimate it. That is a coherent worry. It is not the same as fearing the future.
Progressives. The caricature is that progressives are naïve utopians who want to throw away everything that works or condemn us all to an egalitarian dystopia. The good-faith reading is that progressives see something the rest of us tend to ignore. Power asymmetries are real. Structural causes shape lives in ways individuals cannot opt out of. “Everyone’s voice counts equally” is a sentence that conceals a lot when some people don’t have access to the room. The progressive insistence is that the system as currently arranged leaves real people on the outside, and that this matters. That is a coherent commitment. It is not the same as wanting to torch the building.
These are traditions, not parties, and they don’t map cleanly onto red and blue. Plenty of Democrats carry a conservative streak about institutions, and plenty of Republicans are libertarian about coercion. Turns out humans are complex and they can hold all three of these at once in different contexts and on different timescales. None of them requires you to abandon your own first commitments. What they require is the recognition that the other people in this conversation are working with a partial map of reality (so are you, so am I) and that the partial maps are not random. They track real features of the world that the other maps tend to flatten.
The caricature wins debates. The good-faith reading is what makes dialogue possible. It’s also what spurs curiosity and real problem-solving, instead of the partisan mud-slinging that has prevented policy progress over the past decade plus.
We’re Playing the Wrong Game
I have done the thing I am about to describe. I am a political theorist, I moderate difficult conversations for a living, and I will still find myself, twenty minutes into a discussion with someone whose politics I find genuinely unworkable, listening for the flaw in what they are saying so I can pounce on it. The default setting of the modern political conversation is listening to win, and the default is hard to override.
The shift that matters is the shift from debate to dialogue. They are different games. They have different goals. In a debate the goal is to prove the other side wrong. You listen for the flaw. You steel-man your own position. Politics is a contest in which someone has to lose. The outcome is harder lines and more heat.
In a dialogue the goal is to understand what the other side actually thinks and to surface what they see that you do not. You listen for what is true. You steel-man their position before you respond to it. Politics becomes a shared problem-solving exercise in which the people in the room are trying to build a more accurate picture of what is going on.
Most of us are stuck in debate mode because the media ecosystem we live in is structurally a debate. Cable news is a debate. Twitter (excuse me, X) is a debate. Most of the podcasts you listen to are a debate. We have been trained, every day, to listen for the flaw. Then we wonder why our family dinners feel like cable news.
The first move toward dialogue is the recognition that you can do it without giving up your positions. You can think the other side is wrong about almost everything and still ask them what they actually mean. Curiosity is not concession.
(I really like Mike Lee’s work at the Civility Initiative in this area. You can check out a couple podcast episodes with Mike and me here and here.)
Three Tools, One Shift
The research on depolarization interventions is sobering. Most work a little, then fade. A recent meta-analysis found about a five-point improvement on a hundred-point scale that washes out within two weeks. This is something. It is not a cure.
What works better, consistently, are approaches that involve personal story and genuine curiosity. The variable that shows up in nearly every successful intervention is the same: people ask questions instead of making arguments. That is the move. Everything below is a way to make the move easier.
Looping (Amanda Ripley)
Amanda Ripley, who wrote High Conflict, calls it the looping technique. It is the simplest of the three and the easiest to underestimate. The structure is listen, reflect, check.
You listen closely to what the other person actually says. You reflect it back to them in your own clear, plain language. Then you ask, “Did I get that right?” If you didn’t, you let them correct you. You do this before you respond to the substance.
It feels a little cringe (to quote my 13 year old) the first time you try it, like you are doing a workshop exercise in real life. It also reliably changes the temperature of a conversation. People who feel heard fight less. People who feel mischaracterized fight more. Looping interrupts the second loop before it starts.
Try it once this week, in any conversation, political or not. The technique transfers.
Complexity (Peter Coleman)
Peter Coleman runs the Difficult Conversations Lab at Columbia, and the finding from his lab that I think most surprised even him is this: the most effective way to reduce conflict is not to find common ground. It is to introduce more complexity.
Binary framing (us versus them, red versus blue, my side versus the bad guys) locks people into fight mode. Multiple perspectives and additional layers cool the tribal response. The brain has a harder time hating a position that has six dimensions than one that has two.
Coleman’s practical exercise, and the one I keep recommending to people, is this. Before your next political conversation, list three things you think the other side gets right. Just three. It is harder than it sounds. If you find yourself unable to come up with three, that is information about the size of your phantom.
The goal is not agreement. The goal is a more accurate picture of reality.
Charitable Interpretation (Pluralist Lab)
The Pluralist Lab runs a workshop format called UNDIVIDE US in which participants show their stance on a question with a colored paddle, and then have to make the strongest case for the other side’s view before they make their own. They call this “charitable interpretation, not conversion.” You are not required to change your mind. You are required to demonstrate that you understand the position you disagree with well enough to articulate it in terms its own holders would recognize.
The logic of the exercise is simple. It’s hard to throw stereotypes at someone who is sitting right in front of you, especially when they’ll have a chance to respond. Once you have made the best case for the other side, you cannot unmake it. The landscape becomes more complicated than you assumed, which is the point (see Coleman’s work above).
The portable version for your own life: before a hard conversation, ask yourself what a thoughtful, well-meaning person on the other side would actually say. Then ask the person you are talking to whether you got it right. Notice that this links back to looping. The tools are not separate. They are facets of the same shift.
Where the Action Is
What looping, complexity, and charitable interpretation share is that all three slow down the reactive brain and ask you to get genuinely curious. None of them requires you to change your values. None of them requires you to abandon your positions. You can do all of this and still disagree, vehemently, about the things that actually matter to you. That is the point. The goal is not a world without conflict. It is a world where conflict is productive rather than corrosive.
If you try one of these this week, the question I would ask you to sit with is not “did it work” (you cannot evaluate a single conversation that way) but “where did I feel the most resistance.” Resistance is information. Resistance is usually where the action is.
I am still working out a lot of this myself. I find the affective polarization frame hopeful and I find the perception-gap data hopeful and I also notice, on a regular basis, that I am still listening for the flaw but that I get better at listening each and every time. Hopeful is not the same as easy. The phantom is sticky. The Güngör and Ditto paper finding that’s worth remembering is that the people who walk away end up with bigger phantoms, not smaller ones. There are friendships in my own life that I have let go quiet, and the paper makes me wonder whether the quiet has been doing the work I told myself it was doing. The actual person across from me is, almost always, a person I can talk to.
Your Turn: Your Summer Survival Kit
It’s cookout season, which means a lot of us are about to be standing in a backyard, paper plate in hand, while someone’s uncle says The Thing. The Fourth is just a few days away! So consider this your survival kit for the season.
At the next BBQ, pick the tool that made you most uncomfortable: looping, complexity, or charitable interpretation. Use it once, on the actual person across the picnic table whose politics you find hard. Don’t try to win. Just get curious.
Then tell me what happened in the comments. I read all of them, and the backyard stories are where the rest of us learn what actually works.
If the post was useful, send it to the one person you’ve been quietly drifting from over politics, ideally before you see them this summer. Forward the email and, if the timing feels right, ask to reconnect.
And if you’re new here, this is what The Radical Moderate’s Guide to Life does every week. It refuses the binary and tries to map the real landscape instead of the phantom one. Subscribe and pull up a chair.
I’m curious where you land on this, and which of the three feels most doable in your life. The one that feels most uncomfortable is probably the one to try first.
Resources (in no particular order, some more academic than others) if you want to go deeper:
Mertcan Güngör and Peter H. Ditto, “Political breakups: Interpersonal consequences of polarization,” PNAS Nexus 5(5), May 2026
Shanto Iyengar et al., “The Origins and Consequences of Affective Polarization in the United States,” Annual Review of Political Science (2019)
Joseph Voelkel et al., “Why depolarization is hard,” PNAS (2025)
Amanda Ripley, High Conflict (2021), and goodconflict.org
Peter T. Coleman, The Way Out: How to Overcome Toxic Polarization (2021), and thewayoutofpolarization.com
The Pluralist Lab and UNDIVIDE US, pluralistlab.org
More in Common, “The Perception Gap” (2019)
More from me on this topic (some linked above already):
My podcast interview with Mike Lee’s When We Disagree on not giving up on people



Over 20 hears ago I arrived in a rural mountain community to be a “terminal do-gooder,” as my husband calls it, in the public schools. After a while I realized I was being invited to participate in all kinds of committee meetings among educators in the schools, things I had nothing to do with.
I finally asked the guidance counselor who mostly delivered the invitations what I was doing there. He explained there was a pattern in the community of people getting together to find a solution to a problem or set a course of action, leaving to go out and do their part, and everyone ending up angry about how everyone else had hoodwinked them or not done their part. “We make assumptions and don’t listen to each other. We leave the meeting without being on the same page. You are trying to understand, you ask questions, and you don’t let us leave the room until we’re all on the same page.”
As the years go on I’ve found four things that make me able to do this thing I didn’t know I was doing. I am genuinely curious. I am not involved in or dependent upon the essentially patronage system that controls jobs, including which jobs exist and who gets them, in so many places. I didn’t go to the same schools or churches anyone else did. I am not trying to “belong,” only understand.
I told this story to a young elected county official a while back. She says now when the controversy in meetings starts, usually about who to blame for what went wrong, she channels her “inner Lori.”
She is genuinely curious, she does not care if she is reelected or not and is a small business owner, because of a tragic childhood she is not one of “the right people.” She left the county in high school, did not go to the same schools and churches as our neighbors and is not concerned about being accepted or belonging, only about living and serving in a place she calls home. It seems to be working for her.
I learned about Looping in a conflict resolution seminar. What I've found is that even when all parties involved in a conversation know what it is and why it's being used, it still works. But most people don't know what it is and why it works, and thus using it feels more like a magical empathy and care tool.