Like a lot of people my age, I vividly remember where I was on 9/11. I was sitting in my on-campus apartment at Binghamton University watching the news with friends from NYC. One of their moms had called from Long Island to say a plane had hit the World Trade Center. Our sadness at what we thought was an accident morphed into disbelieving horror as we watched the second plane hit live on TV. I can still feel the visceral dread that dripped through me in that moment; a fear of the unknown ahead and a certainty that the world would never be the same again. In many ways, that was true. But in a lot of important ways, it wasn’t.
What strikes me as so important about 9/11 is what it tells us about the enduring aspects of human nature, at least some of which undermine narratives we’ve been taught our whole lives.
We see those lessons across the stories that came out of that day.
One story that made the social media rounds earlier this month was the story of Heather Penney. On the morning of September 11, 2001 Penney and Marc Sasseville had been ordered up from Andrews Air Force Base to stop United Flight 93 before it reached Washington. Penney took off with no missiles on her F-16; there hadn’t been time to load them. The plan was to ram the passenger jet: Sasseville would take the cockpit, Penney would take the tail, and neither of them expected to survive.
Penney and Sasseville never had to make that choice because somewhere over Pennsylvania a planeful of strangers, including a PR executive and a rugby player and a software salesman and thirty-odd other people, took a vote in the back of a hijacked airliner and rushed the cockpit first. Their choice and the choices Penney and Sasseville didn’t have to make tell us something pretty powerful about human nature. On that sunny morning there were actually layers of people willing to die, some of whom had pledged to serve their country knowing this was a possible outcome and many others who had not. If you read about the phone calls they made in those last minutes, what they were dying for wasn’t the country exactly. It was each other and the people on the ground they would never meet but whose lives they thought they could save.
The 25th anniversary of 9/11 was earlier this month and that anniversary, along with a few other personal experiences from this year, got me thinking a lot about what human nature entails and why we get it so wrong.
9/11 gave us a lot of stories of heroism, which is one reason it’s such a powerful connection point for the country. Some stories are those like Penney and Sasseville, where people did what they were trained to do but in deeply extraordinary ways. Firefighters and police officers went up those stairs knowing they might never come out. Three hundred forty-three members of the FDNY did not. FDNY members were trained and paid, but they were also still voluntary in every way that counts: nobody can make anyone walk up stairs knowing there’s a very good chance they won’t come back down. That’s heroism of the kind we build institutions to produce, but nothing determines the individual level choice to sacrifice your life for strangers.
But other heroes were people who, if you listen to the degrowth left or the post-liberal right, shouldn’t have been heroes at all. Welles Crowther was a 24-year-old equities trader, also known as the man in the red bandanna. He went back into the South Tower again and again and got somewhere around a dozen people out before it came down on him. Rick Rescorla was a corporate security director at Morgan Stanley who had spent years annoying his employer with evacuation drills; he got some 2,700 people out before going back in and never coming out. The critics of “neoliberal” individualistic capitalism, the people who spend their careers explaining that markets hollow out our capacity for sacrifice, would not have predicted any of this. The shills of corporate America ran back into a melting building instead of away from it.
To be fair, I don’t think the critique of unrestrained individualism is completely empty. There’s a little bit of something to it. But it doesn’t touch the fact that humans, including equities traders, are capable of enormous self-sacrifice when the moment demands it. That capacity wasn’t installed by the firm. It’s written into our DNA.
There were, of course, a lot of people who failed that day, but the biggest failures didn’t come from the average citizen, they came from leadership. 9/11 was a failure of the Taliban’s leadership in Afghanistan. It was a failure of American security leadership, foreign policy leadership, and many other kinds of leadership along the way. It was a failure of leadership at nearly every level that had a chance to stop it. What it was not was a failure of citizens. Afghan citizens did not decide to attack the United States. American citizens did not fail to keep the country safe. Nineteen men, and the political and organizational structures that produced them, did this. The rest of us, on both sides of the world, had to make the hard decisions that failed leadership make inevitable. And on that day, just like so many others, citizens outshone their leaders across the board.
The real Lord of the Flies
At some point in our young lives, most of us are forced to read Golding’s Lord of the Flies and therefore most of us are familiar with the plot: Boys stranded on an island, the veneer of civilization peels off, the conch gets smashed, Piggy dies. It is on most high school syllabi in the country (and it’s the main reason Golding won the Nobel Prize in literature) because it flatters an idea we already hold: that underneath the manners, people are monsters, and only the adults with the guns keep the monsters down. It’s Hobbes in literary form and in many ways it forms the foundation for the current belief that human life is solitary, poor, nasty, brutish and short (except now more than ever, it isn’t).
But it’s worth comparing Golding/Hobbesian pessimism with real humans on the ground. In 1965, the scenario in Lord of the Flies actually happened. Six Tongan boys, bored at their Catholic boarding school, stole a fishing boat and got caught in a storm. They drifted for eight days and washed up on the island of ‘Ata, a rock in the Pacific that had been uninhabited for a century. Rutger Bregman dug the story up for his book Humankind and it’s worth reading his whole account; almost nothing in it matches the novel.
The boys were there for fifteen months. Instead of social cooperation disintegrating over power and status, the boys set up a garden, a rainwater catchment, chicken pens, a badminton court, and a fire they managed to keep burning the entire time. They worked in pairs on a rota. They had a rule for fights: you took a time-out, cooled off, and apologized (I still try to enforce this one on my kids and fail, but maybe the stakes aren’t high enough in our corner of suburbia). One boy, Stephen, fell off a cliff and broke his leg. Rather than heartlessly leaving him to die (which would have helped their food ration situation), the others climbed down, carried him back up, set the leg with sticks and leaves, and did his share of the work until it healed. It healed. (Margaret Mead is often claimed to have said that the first sign of civilization is a broken femur that’s healed). When an Australian sea captain finally found the boys over a year later, the doctor who examined them was astonished at how healthy they were.
The boys who cared for a friend with a broken leg, at real cost to themselves, on a rock in the middle of the ocean with no adults and no state, weren’t outliers. They were doing what people do. Golding’s version is the outlier. He once said he understood the Nazis because he was “of that sort by nature.” I sometimes wonder if his novel is a portrait of what one unhappy man believed about himself while we’ve been assigning it as if it were data, shaking our heads sadly about the cruelty of humankind, all the while people are quietly taking care of each other all around us.
Rwanda was a policy
Well, if people are so cooperative, the counterargument goes, what about genocide? What about famine? What about the entire twentieth century?
Again, I think it’s worth separating humans in leadership from average humans. It turns out that famine and genocide aren’t really natural events in any sense of the term. They’re political and they’re almost always engineered.
Rwanda in 1994 was organized; it consisted of leaders, lists, radio broadcasts, militias trained and armed by a government, and a plan. Similarly, the famines that killed tens of millions over the last two centuries were in Ukraine, in China, in Ireland, and in Bengal. Blight and cyclone were real in Ireland and Bengal but what turned crop failure into mass death was policy. In Ukraine and China the policy was the famine. Amartya Sen made the point decades ago that no substantial famine has ever occurred in a functioning democracy with a free press. His point was that famine and genocide are policy and leadership choices, not the natural state of human life, and they’re most effective when most people have no idea what’s going on. And they’re most effective when done in secret because most humans don’t want to kill or starve each other. It’s as simple as that.
Starvation is a policy. Genocide is a policy. They’re not endogenous to the human experience. They’re what happens when political structures channel our cooperative instincts toward killing instead of toward each other. It turns out that it takes an enormous amount of organization to do that, because it runs against the human grain.
The obvious objection might be Christopher Browning’s Ordinary Men: the Rwandan militias, like the reserve policemen who shot Jews in Poland, were neighbors, not monsters. A skeptic will say that proves Golding right, but on closer inspection it proves the opposite. If neighbors killed neighbors on instinct, nobody would need the lists, the radio, the training, the arms, and the plan. The sheer amount of machinery it takes to get ordinary people to engage in this kind of cruelty is the evidence for my side. And the two experiments everyone cites to prove otherwise have not aged well. Milgram’s obedience studies turn out, on the archival record, to involve far more resistance and far more experimenter pressure than the textbook version admits. The Stanford Prison Experiment was worse: the guards were coached, and the cruelty was at least partly engineered by the people running it. In contrast, the disaster-sociology literature, which Rebecca Solnit summarized in A Paradise Built in Hell, finds evidence against Hobbes: after earthquakes and after attacks, panic and looting are rare and mutual aid is the norm.
Humans have always been better than their political leadership. That is why institutions, not leaders, are what make us better. Leaders come and go, and a shocking number of them are the worst people in the room. Institutions determine whether the worst person in the room can get the rest of the room to do something terrible. We’re learning that painful lesson all over again now in 2026.
Sowell’s binary (not his fault but ours)
Thomas Sowell’s A Conflict of Visions is a book I assign and admire, but I also think i't’s done some damage, perhaps primarily due to its very popularity. The constrained vision holds that human nature is fixed and limited and that institutions have to work with that material. The unconstrained vision holds that human nature is malleable and perfectible and that the right institutions can remake it. Sowell is pretty careful with this distinction, but as is often the case the way the framework gets used is not careful at all. It collapses into a binary between utopianism and realism, which in practice means Rousseau’s perfectible man versus Hobbes’s nasty mushroom men. You are either a naïf or a realist, and the realists have all the good lines. (William Blake famously argued that Milton was inherently hamstrung while writing Paradise Lost. Satan is just a much more interesting character in part because goodness so easily reads as mundane.) But between Sowell, Golding and a battering ram of anti-liberal writers on both the left and right, a generation of readers came away believing that any talk of human cooperation is Rousseauian naivety, and that the only grown-up position is to assume the worst.
I, for one, refuse the binary and it’s not empirically wrong to do so. The reality is somewhere in the messy middle, and the middle operates in all four dimensions rather than existing as a one-dimensional compromise between the poles. That messy middle is the work of Elinor Ostrom, who spent her career documenting ordinary people managing shared resources without either a Leviathan or a commune. It’s also the work of David Sloan Wilson, my undergraduate mentor, who argued, against most of his field, that cooperation is baked into us at the level of evolutionary biology. We are social in our very bones. We cannot live without each other. Not just for Lockean convenience, but in a real contingent way. Our brains can’t even develop normally in the absence of other humans. We need each other to grow, not just to survive. We are intensely cooperative, profoundly social, and while that cooperation and sociality is constrained, it’s constrained toward each other, not away.
I’ll be the first to admit that the constraint is real. Cooperation requires incentives. It can turn in the wrong direction if it isn’t channeled. (After all, the Mafia and the Rwandan militias were cooperating too.) Prosocial cooperation needs structures, institutions, and aligned incentives. Large-scale nation-state living is not instinctive or easy for us; nothing in our evolutionary history prepared us to trust strangers at the scale of three hundred million. So institutions and incentives push on us in ways that make us better or much, much worse.
But the raw material is not Hobbesian. It’s not nature red in tooth and claw. And my insistence here isn’t optimism. It’s not a naive hope for a better future. It’s an empirical description of what humans are actually like when they’re not being used as tools for someone else’s agenda.
Look for the Bobs
Most of the empirical evidence for this though isn’t on hijacked airplanes or Pacific islands. It is in the pew in front of you. Or, if you’re not a church-goer, look around your community to wherever you see people quietly doing the work, whatever that work is, and you’ll find Bobs.
My Bob read at mass almost every week for years. He and his wife Teri were some of the first people I met at our parish after I converted and I sat behind them at mass every week. Bob’s place at the lectern was something I took for granted until, a few weeks before Easter this year, he wasn’t there anymore. After serving as a lector and running our fourth grade faith formation group while grappling with stage 4 cancer for well over a year, he passed away.
Bob and Teri were married for 52 years. They raised three daughters - it was that connection that prompted them to turn around in the pew six years ago to ask me questions about my three girls. They were among the first people to welcome me when I joined the parish in 2019, the year my husband was mobilized and I was hanging onto my sanity by spiderweb thin threads. Bob served on committees and community boards and taught faith formation and did the unglamorous institutional work that keeps a community running. His obituary reads like a thousand others you’ve likely skimmed: devoted father and parishioner, veteran, PTA member, omnipresent volunteer.
We read obituaries like this constantly. They’re everywhere. Quietly extraordinary people who devoted themselves to their families and their neighbors and who, by any measure that actually matters, changed the world in concrete and durable ways.
And we give them, like God in Paradise Lost, almost none of our mental bandwidth. Satan is more interesting in part because the Bobs are, while extraordinary, all around us. They’re like the water we swim in or the air we breath and they don’t demand a lot from us, by disposition. Instead, our media diets, our political lives, our emotional energy, all of it goes to the dividers, the splitters, and the loudest people who want to burn institutions down. Satan is more interesting but that’s at least in part because he’s so much more rare.
Negativity bias is brutally efficient. The driver who cuts you off on the way to work robs your mood for the day but the ten people who waved you in or held the door are vague memories as you trudge to your office. This isn’t a character flaw. It’s in part how we are wired and in part how we ourselves choose to read the world. Bad experiences register harder and remain longer than good, which means our running tally of the world is systematically skewed toward the worst of what happened rather than the most accurate account of it. The ones tearing things apart are impossible to ignore.
Selective attention also changes what you believe is real. A lot of people who are overwhelmed by everything going wrong right now (including those who encourage young people to despair, which I find harder to forgive) are missing the counter-evidence, because the counter-evidence is quiet and looks like Bob.
Human choice and agency
The good news is that like the heroes of 9/11 and like the Tongan schoolboys, we get to choose, at two levels.
Within certain constraints, we get to choose the institutions we live under. I’d like to see a world where we build institutions that support prosocial behavior and make people more cooperative and more caring. We actually know a fair amount about how to do that, because Ostrom wrote it down. And we do get better at it, in fits and spurts, with mistakes in between, as we learn about leadership failures and how to constrain them.
And then, as individuals, we get to choose how we show up for the people in our lives even when the institutions are jacked. We get to decide whether to treat people with grace and give them the benefit of the doubt, or whether we fall prey to the worst aspects of our current institutional failures and make the situation worse. We get to decide whether we succumb to the despair of doomscrolling or whether, like Bob, we keep showing up with a smile because that’s the real world. We get to choose to focus on the multitude of Bobs or the isolated Golding. We get to choose when we capitulate and when we resist.
If institutions are the water we swim in, as individuals we can choose to make that water cleaner and, at baseline, we’re still responsible for the swimming.
I’m teaching my daughter’s 9th grade confirmation class and we had our first class last night. When I ran into Teri at Sunday mass she told me Bob would be proud I had stepped into that role, and I know he would have been. Service to God, to his family, to his community and to his nation was just who he is. I’m not nearly as good a person as Bob was, but I do think a lot about him as I do lesson planning.
Everything in that confirmation class is about choice. Confirmation is, in fact, this critical leverage point in a person’s life - around age 14 - when we become capable of the most important kinds of choices out there. It’s not a coincidence that many other cultures and religious traditions mark the capacity for independent human choice as happening around this age. It’s when we become members of our various communities and start to learn what that means. And it’s when we start to learn the power of choice. We choose whether to connect to God. We choose whether to connect to our neighbors. We choose whether to look at human nature as fundamentally good or fundamentally bad, and that choice isn’t a neutral reading of the evidence. It shapes what we see. The kid who believes people are monsters will find the monsters. The kid who believes people are mostly like Bob will find the Bobs, and there are a lot more of them.
So, at your best, strive to be like the 9/11 heroes (but hope you never have to face their choices). Be like Bob. Be like the kids on ‘Ata who carried their friend up the cliff. These are not exceptions to human nature. They are the vast majority of people in the world, when political leaders leave them alone.
But on a much less existential level, choose to see the Bobs, because we get to choose what we see, what we focus on and the kind of people we give our attention and bandwidth to in the moment. We get to choose what messages we put out into the world and whose messages we share.
The Bobs, the Welles, and the Tongan boys who carried their friend for months are the real story. Satan, as charming as Milton made him, is the outlier. And as we’ve learned from history the Satans out there often have plans for us.
We choose whether we cooperate with him or with each other.
Your Turn
Today I’d love to hear about your Bobs or your Welles or whoever else you know of who quietly Did the Thing when it mattered most. I’d also like to hear your thoughts on human nature, if there’s something I missed or overlooked or something worth considering. But mostly today feels like a good day to celebrate the Bobs out there; please share!



A bit late to the comments courtesy of a busy last week. I don't have anything significant to add, I thoroughly appreciated reading Lauren's post and all the comments, so my appreciation to all of you for comments that are so thoughtful. For me as a lifelong technically focused project engineer, reading these more philosophically focused essays and comments are very educational (and make me think more!)
Outstanding piece. I hope to be a Bob.