A bit late to the comments courtesy of a busy last week. I don't have anything significant to add, I thoroughly appreciated reading Lauren's post and all the comments, so my appreciation to all of you for comments that are so thoughtful. For me as a lifelong technically focused project engineer, reading these more philosophically focused essays and comments are very educational (and make me think more!)
Here’s an excerpt from my dissertation. Based on my research, you’re barking up the right tree. Historically and across cultures, there are specific variables that indicate organized group violence will occur. But it takes a lot of work to get the average human there.
This is great, Kane! I did a quick skim and am adding it to my "to read" folder to dig into in more depth. Thanks for sharing and for providing additional concrete evidence that we're better than we think.
And also "The Goodness Paradox" by Richard Wrangham which gets into the biology and anthropologic evidence. Super interesting stuff if you're a group violence nerd like me.
I’m an outlier in this conversation since I think a huge part of our problems begin and end with believing in a fundamental human nature as defined and influenced by a limited, narrow understanding of evolution applied to disciplines outside of biology and genetics. I find ample evidence over time and in experience to consider the approach simplistic, sometimes deterministic. That said I’ll take the other assignment.
My Bob is a Peggy. At 90 years old her church is trying to figure out how to sustain her ministry to the sick and homebound that now encompasses not only members of her parish or denomination, but people in need in nursing homes across her city. The problem is finding enough people to replace Peggy and her now aging team who have never tried to figure out how to do the work efficiently, but well, respecting all the humans involved without regard to their nature and without any incentives or rewards unless you count the physical and mental health benefits of doing this kind of relationship work week in and week out in pretty much anonymity. It’s a bunch of amazingly healthy people in mind and body doing all this work.
….and in closing I will point out that the fictional group in the Lord of the Flies was British, patterned after one set of cultural expectations, while in the real story the real boys were Tongan, running away from an Anglican boarding school.
While it's comforting to look on the bright side, and the Tonga boys case study does provide a potential refutation of LOTF's scenario, there are also many more case studies, with excellent and deep documentation, that support the LOTF's reality.
The ones that come first to mind are shipwrecked crews--mostly of British ships. We know the details because they kept detailed logs and journals, even as they descended into LOTF's barbarity. There are many other cases that were not so well-documented, and thus not as well known.
Mutiny on the Bounty is an excellent case study. The mutineers ended up on a remote island. When they were contacted by British ships, something like 5-10 years later, only a couple were still alive. They had done Piggies to the rest, through the years.
Another illustrative case study is told in a book: The Wager: A Tale of Shipwreck, Mutiny and Murder. These weren't mutineers, they were the military officers and crew of a ship that went down in a storm. In the course of 2-3 years of being stranded on an island, their men's actions were virtually identical to LOTF. In fact, I'd bet that Golding used this case as the model for his LOTF plot.
So, it's likely that Golding's work was not a reflection of "an unhappy man's beliefs about himself," but rather an astute observer who used historical records to ground his fictional warning to society.
I’d like to amplify your observation that these are mostly observations of what happened on British ships. I think of Golding as an astute observer of his own culture and his work a warning to that culture which was extrapolated to make predictions about human nature not necessarily inherent in other cultures.
With respect to “Humans have always been better than their political leadership,” one reason is that political leadership tends to draw in narcissistic and even sociopathic personalities. These types tend to lust after power to a degree that “normal” people don’t, and tend not to be moved by the suffering that their actions (or lack thereof) cause.
Thanks for your reply, it provides enough information to fully understand your original comment. This illustrates the challenge of interpretating literature, we all bring our bias and world views with us. I like the "proper" interpretation better. It gives the book more "heft" than the Hobbesian approach.
I really enjoyed this article, but am left with the question, why is it that Satan is more interesting to us? This isn't a contemporary phenomena. For example, the newspaper logic of 'if it bleeds, it leads' or all of the religious sects finding the devil in all aspects of human life throughout history.
Negativity bias has strong evolutionary roots. If you ignore swaying grass when there's a leopard hiding in it, you don't get to make that mistake again. On the flip side, if you think swaying grass is a leopard and it's not, that's a mistake you get to make again and you're rewarded for the mistake, in some sense. There's a kind of irony here that I think about a lot: humans are better than our own intuitions of the world have evolved to be. We're biased toward the negative not because it tracks truth but because it tracks how errors in our beliefs played out in our ancestral environment.
The consequences in modern life are not great. Not just what I've laid out here, but in parenting, criminal justice policy, immigration policy, etc. Just on the parenting question, the assumption many in my parenting cohort make that most adults are likely pedophiles means that kids grow up without a village and that their independence is stifled because they can no longer ride bikes around without adult supervision. Negativity bias against strangers likely made sense in tribal societies, but makes very little sense in modern liberal societies with relatively low crime rates and in fact is often actively harmful.
Thanks for your reply, Lauren. I guess the challenge for us today is to stop amplifying the negativity, but we are up against the very lucrative business of tribal warfare (Again the issue of our institutions failing us).
I forwarded your article to several friends. I think that's the highest compliment I can give somone. 😁
Thanks so much, Michael! I appreciate you reading and commenting more than you know. I'm lucky to have readers who engage and force me to dig deeper on questions like this one. I 100% agree that it's going to take a concerted effort to push back against the incentives that negativity bias creates in media, social media, and politics. It's not an easy task and I don't have good solutions other than starting at the individual level, at least for now.
I always found the Satan in Paradise Lost the most interesting character because he came across as so very human, refusing to bend the knee. A talented and charismatic individual, he wouldn’t do what he was told, accept what he was told, follow. His pride got the best of him in the end, of course, but what human who has not been beaten down and made to follow doesn’t find something interesting about someone who wants to follow their own path and define themselves? As a junior in high school I got an English award because the teacher said not only had I dutifully read Paradise Lost when assigned, I went on to read Paradise regained for fun.
…and, of course, the implications of finding Satan interesting as a character in metaphorical fiction for those of us who see the character as just that, a metaphor in a metaphorical world, are very different, I think, from negativity bias or marketing using fear. Satan is for me one half of a metaphor for the problem of binary thinking, an interesting one.
“that underneath the manners, people are monsters, and only the adults with the guns keep the monsters down.” This interpretation of LOTF has always been a misreading of the story. The myth is not the story, it’s the misinterpretation of the story.
That might very well be true, j.e., but the interpretation I and many who read it in high school took away was a general belief that when you strip the civilizational skins off humans we're worse than animals. There's an additional misconception there, of course, which is that our social skins are literally part of who we are, so stripping them away becomes almost tautological. Of course we stop being human if you remove half of what makes us human in the first place.
More broadly though, my concern with Golding and Sowell's works are less the works themselves than how they're interpreted. And many people interpret both as examples of humanity's inherent evil.
Yes, I think many critics did a great disservice to the book and thus to many students reading and subsequent interpretations based on the misreading. The boys were never inherently evil. They were a reflection of their developmental scaffolding or lack thereof from the culture from whence they came. Also, I’m not suggesting that the boys’ moral injury began with the plane crash, or that the crash somehow turned innocent children into savages. The injury, as I see it, was already part of the developmental story they carried with them; the crash simply removed the adult relationships and structures that had helped contain and shape it. What follows on the island is less a revelation of some hidden evil than a progression of developmental disruption, moral confusion, and accumulating injury that the boys are simply not equipped to process on their own.
A bit late to the comments courtesy of a busy last week. I don't have anything significant to add, I thoroughly appreciated reading Lauren's post and all the comments, so my appreciation to all of you for comments that are so thoughtful. For me as a lifelong technically focused project engineer, reading these more philosophically focused essays and comments are very educational (and make me think more!)
Outstanding piece. I hope to be a Bob.
https://thegoodideafairy.substack.com/p/the-victim-identity-model-the-pathology
Here’s an excerpt from my dissertation. Based on my research, you’re barking up the right tree. Historically and across cultures, there are specific variables that indicate organized group violence will occur. But it takes a lot of work to get the average human there.
This is great, Kane! I did a quick skim and am adding it to my "to read" folder to dig into in more depth. Thanks for sharing and for providing additional concrete evidence that we're better than we think.
Woohoo, thank you Lauren. Another good one to check out is https://worksinprogress.co/issue/the-prehistoric-psychopath/ which came out after mine. It's really good and goes back into pre-history versus mine which stopped in the 1600s.
And also "The Goodness Paradox" by Richard Wrangham which gets into the biology and anthropologic evidence. Super interesting stuff if you're a group violence nerd like me.
https://theclassicshelf.substack.com/p/would-you-survive-the-island-a-free?r=f9vfg&utm_medium=ios
I’m an outlier in this conversation since I think a huge part of our problems begin and end with believing in a fundamental human nature as defined and influenced by a limited, narrow understanding of evolution applied to disciplines outside of biology and genetics. I find ample evidence over time and in experience to consider the approach simplistic, sometimes deterministic. That said I’ll take the other assignment.
My Bob is a Peggy. At 90 years old her church is trying to figure out how to sustain her ministry to the sick and homebound that now encompasses not only members of her parish or denomination, but people in need in nursing homes across her city. The problem is finding enough people to replace Peggy and her now aging team who have never tried to figure out how to do the work efficiently, but well, respecting all the humans involved without regard to their nature and without any incentives or rewards unless you count the physical and mental health benefits of doing this kind of relationship work week in and week out in pretty much anonymity. It’s a bunch of amazingly healthy people in mind and body doing all this work.
….and in closing I will point out that the fictional group in the Lord of the Flies was British, patterned after one set of cultural expectations, while in the real story the real boys were Tongan, running away from an Anglican boarding school.
While it's comforting to look on the bright side, and the Tonga boys case study does provide a potential refutation of LOTF's scenario, there are also many more case studies, with excellent and deep documentation, that support the LOTF's reality.
The ones that come first to mind are shipwrecked crews--mostly of British ships. We know the details because they kept detailed logs and journals, even as they descended into LOTF's barbarity. There are many other cases that were not so well-documented, and thus not as well known.
Mutiny on the Bounty is an excellent case study. The mutineers ended up on a remote island. When they were contacted by British ships, something like 5-10 years later, only a couple were still alive. They had done Piggies to the rest, through the years.
Another illustrative case study is told in a book: The Wager: A Tale of Shipwreck, Mutiny and Murder. These weren't mutineers, they were the military officers and crew of a ship that went down in a storm. In the course of 2-3 years of being stranded on an island, their men's actions were virtually identical to LOTF. In fact, I'd bet that Golding used this case as the model for his LOTF plot.
So, it's likely that Golding's work was not a reflection of "an unhappy man's beliefs about himself," but rather an astute observer who used historical records to ground his fictional warning to society.
Golding was a WWII vet that was at Normandy, that likely colored his view of humanity quite a bit.
I’d like to amplify your observation that these are mostly observations of what happened on British ships. I think of Golding as an astute observer of his own culture and his work a warning to that culture which was extrapolated to make predictions about human nature not necessarily inherent in other cultures.
With respect to “Humans have always been better than their political leadership,” one reason is that political leadership tends to draw in narcissistic and even sociopathic personalities. These types tend to lust after power to a degree that “normal” people don’t, and tend not to be moved by the suffering that their actions (or lack thereof) cause.
Thanks for your reply, it provides enough information to fully understand your original comment. This illustrates the challenge of interpretating literature, we all bring our bias and world views with us. I like the "proper" interpretation better. It gives the book more "heft" than the Hobbesian approach.
I really enjoyed this article, but am left with the question, why is it that Satan is more interesting to us? This isn't a contemporary phenomena. For example, the newspaper logic of 'if it bleeds, it leads' or all of the religious sects finding the devil in all aspects of human life throughout history.
Negativity bias has strong evolutionary roots. If you ignore swaying grass when there's a leopard hiding in it, you don't get to make that mistake again. On the flip side, if you think swaying grass is a leopard and it's not, that's a mistake you get to make again and you're rewarded for the mistake, in some sense. There's a kind of irony here that I think about a lot: humans are better than our own intuitions of the world have evolved to be. We're biased toward the negative not because it tracks truth but because it tracks how errors in our beliefs played out in our ancestral environment.
The consequences in modern life are not great. Not just what I've laid out here, but in parenting, criminal justice policy, immigration policy, etc. Just on the parenting question, the assumption many in my parenting cohort make that most adults are likely pedophiles means that kids grow up without a village and that their independence is stifled because they can no longer ride bikes around without adult supervision. Negativity bias against strangers likely made sense in tribal societies, but makes very little sense in modern liberal societies with relatively low crime rates and in fact is often actively harmful.
Thanks for your reply, Lauren. I guess the challenge for us today is to stop amplifying the negativity, but we are up against the very lucrative business of tribal warfare (Again the issue of our institutions failing us).
I forwarded your article to several friends. I think that's the highest compliment I can give somone. 😁
Thanks so much, Michael! I appreciate you reading and commenting more than you know. I'm lucky to have readers who engage and force me to dig deeper on questions like this one. I 100% agree that it's going to take a concerted effort to push back against the incentives that negativity bias creates in media, social media, and politics. It's not an easy task and I don't have good solutions other than starting at the individual level, at least for now.
I always found the Satan in Paradise Lost the most interesting character because he came across as so very human, refusing to bend the knee. A talented and charismatic individual, he wouldn’t do what he was told, accept what he was told, follow. His pride got the best of him in the end, of course, but what human who has not been beaten down and made to follow doesn’t find something interesting about someone who wants to follow their own path and define themselves? As a junior in high school I got an English award because the teacher said not only had I dutifully read Paradise Lost when assigned, I went on to read Paradise regained for fun.
…and, of course, the implications of finding Satan interesting as a character in metaphorical fiction for those of us who see the character as just that, a metaphor in a metaphorical world, are very different, I think, from negativity bias or marketing using fear. Satan is for me one half of a metaphor for the problem of binary thinking, an interesting one.
“that underneath the manners, people are monsters, and only the adults with the guns keep the monsters down.” This interpretation of LOTF has always been a misreading of the story. The myth is not the story, it’s the misinterpretation of the story.
What is the myth? What is the correct interpretation?
If you read the post, the myth is that Lord of the Flies is about innate evil. The proper interpretation is that children acted out due to trauma and a lack of developmental scaffolding. https://johnmoyermedlpcncc.substack.com/p/reframing-lord-of-the-flies?r=3p5dh&utm_campaign=post-expanded-share&utm_medium=web
That might very well be true, j.e., but the interpretation I and many who read it in high school took away was a general belief that when you strip the civilizational skins off humans we're worse than animals. There's an additional misconception there, of course, which is that our social skins are literally part of who we are, so stripping them away becomes almost tautological. Of course we stop being human if you remove half of what makes us human in the first place.
More broadly though, my concern with Golding and Sowell's works are less the works themselves than how they're interpreted. And many people interpret both as examples of humanity's inherent evil.
Yes, I think many critics did a great disservice to the book and thus to many students reading and subsequent interpretations based on the misreading. The boys were never inherently evil. They were a reflection of their developmental scaffolding or lack thereof from the culture from whence they came. Also, I’m not suggesting that the boys’ moral injury began with the plane crash, or that the crash somehow turned innocent children into savages. The injury, as I see it, was already part of the developmental story they carried with them; the crash simply removed the adult relationships and structures that had helped contain and shape it. What follows on the island is less a revelation of some hidden evil than a progression of developmental disruption, moral confusion, and accumulating injury that the boys are simply not equipped to process on their own.
Great Art doesn’t have a proper interpretation. The experience of great art is different for everyone and yet remains great Art.
Exactly. Which is why I challenged the status quo interpretation of LOTF as being about innate evil or a Hobbsian universe.