Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Frans's avatar

Excellent and thoughtful essay with really good examples. Of course your title says it politicized expertise does not deserve trust. I can modify your question: "what is the thing I currently trust because the experts told me to, that I’ve never once verified for myself" slightly and it becomes a lot more difficult to address: "what is the thing I used to (have to?) trust because those who were recognized as experts told me to, that I’ve never once felt the need to verify or had the ability to verify for myself".

One way to verify something is to see what happens if I don't rust the experts, but especially when it comes to issues relates to personal health, that may be risky. What would have happened if I had not gotten a Covid Vaccine and some boosters: would I have ended up in the hospital if I had contracted Covid and been on a breathing machine, or would I have lost my sense of smell. In other words, too risky not to trust out of hand.

Another complication in the verification option is that the thing or phenomenon to trust is too complex for me to verify or where the opinions of experts differ so much that I simply don't have the (intellectual) ability to verify. Take a current hot issue: are extreme weather events the result of climate change related warming? I can show you half a dozen articles where experts prove that they are, but also an article or two with equally impressive graphs that show very clearly that they are not (statistically). So which experts, all with PhD's do I trust?

Life in general is about probabilities, not certainties, and trusting advice from experts can often be a trade-off: is the risk of not trusting without verifying worth it, is it particularly relevant to me or my family to verify, how would I verify in this increasingly complex world.

We live in a world where sound bites tend to be more impactful than reasoned explanations, so trust the experts wasa a good sound bite until it wasn't, or until the experts lost the humility to accept that there might be some nuance to their claims.

Mid class partisan's avatar

Regarding medicine, if you can’t get a PCP because of money, your going to seek information elsewhere. As for myself I so wanted public schools to be wrecked because they failed me. Please note my culinary school did not. My tune changed with my own daughter.

9 more comments...

Ready for more?