11 Comments
User's avatar
Frans's avatar

Excellent and thoughtful essay with really good examples. Of course your title says it politicized expertise does not deserve trust. I can modify your question: "what is the thing I currently trust because the experts told me to, that I’ve never once verified for myself" slightly and it becomes a lot more difficult to address: "what is the thing I used to (have to?) trust because those who were recognized as experts told me to, that I’ve never once felt the need to verify or had the ability to verify for myself".

One way to verify something is to see what happens if I don't rust the experts, but especially when it comes to issues relates to personal health, that may be risky. What would have happened if I had not gotten a Covid Vaccine and some boosters: would I have ended up in the hospital if I had contracted Covid and been on a breathing machine, or would I have lost my sense of smell. In other words, too risky not to trust out of hand.

Another complication in the verification option is that the thing or phenomenon to trust is too complex for me to verify or where the opinions of experts differ so much that I simply don't have the (intellectual) ability to verify. Take a current hot issue: are extreme weather events the result of climate change related warming? I can show you half a dozen articles where experts prove that they are, but also an article or two with equally impressive graphs that show very clearly that they are not (statistically). So which experts, all with PhD's do I trust?

Life in general is about probabilities, not certainties, and trusting advice from experts can often be a trade-off: is the risk of not trusting without verifying worth it, is it particularly relevant to me or my family to verify, how would I verify in this increasingly complex world.

We live in a world where sound bites tend to be more impactful than reasoned explanations, so trust the experts wasa a good sound bite until it wasn't, or until the experts lost the humility to accept that there might be some nuance to their claims.

Sam's avatar

I'm not sure experts were ever humble. In fact, I'm fairly sure they used to be more arrogant in an absolute sense. The phrenologist thinks more of himself relative to his subject than most current academics even have a category for. What they were was less challenged.

Mid class partisan's avatar

Regarding medicine, if you can’t get a PCP because of money, your going to seek information elsewhere. As for myself I so wanted public schools to be wrecked because they failed me. Please note my culinary school did not. My tune changed with my own daughter.

Lauren Hall's avatar

This is a great point too. People get the information they can access and/or afford. This is one reason I defend ChatGPT for medicine more than other academics I know. If the alternative to a smart AI tool (with reasonably decent guardrails at the moment) is Reddit or your next door neighbor, you're actually very likely better off with ChatGPT. People need to pay more attention to what the actual alternatives are for the real people out there trying to navigate the world.

Sam's avatar
Aug 13Edited

As someone a bit less willing to give a chatbot fed on (among other things but largely) Reddit and the like more shrift than Reddit itself, I think this is a good point well put.

Strongly opinionated people will sometimes - by no means always - have nuanced allowances. "Crypto is a multilevel scam of self-dealing...but I am glad that it has apparently helped some people in extremely dire legal and financial straits receive aid that their government would otherwise hinder." "Psychic readings are cons preying on the hurting...but some people just enjoy them and that's fine." "Government is full of crooks...but my friend on the city counsel is one of the good ones."

The thing is, even if people hear the nuance, they know what the lede is. I think this is one way people taking loud albeit principled stances on some controversial topic - often these days it'll be genAI - are often viewed as more arrogant than they see themselves. In their (and mine sometimes I'm sure) minds, we do have a nuanced, understanding opinion; it's just more important that the baseline be condemnatory. I understand why many only hear the condemnation. It's good to front-line the understanding.

Lori's avatar

“If she refuted the photographic evidence it wasn’t because she truly believed it false, but that she ‘wouldn’t put it past them.’” I love the stories about your grandmother because I know so many of your grandmother. I trust them. I even trust some experts.

This logic applies to applies to voting. I don’t know anyone my age or older who doesn’t know for a fact that some local and district elections in some places were “stolen” at some point in time. As someone deeply embedded in the process in different ways over time, I don’t believe any federal elections we keep talking about in recent years have been, I feel confident they have not. But telling people who were affected by stolen elections in their lifetime …paper ballots were often involved, overt corruption always was… to trust the experts now running the system is counterproductive. Their experience says, “wouldn’t put it past them.” If they are among those who actually participated in stealing elections they “wouldn’t put it past us.”

Lauren Hall's avatar

Great example! And it's so true. A lot of people's skepticism of expertise or formal institutions is based on experience. The experience might not be perfectly applicable, as your local vs. federal voting example demonstrates, but decrying distrustful people as quacks or cranks not only doesn't solve anything but further undermines whatever trust is left. We're much better off getting curious about people's experiences, showing that we trust their specific expertise about their own lives (my grandmother certainly had a lot of expertise in her own domain), and finding out how we can bridge whatever gaps exist. But it's not a one-way street and too often we assume it is. The "just get with the program and trust us!" narrative is deeply unhelpful and quite obviously harmful.

Lori's avatar

It can be so helpful, a learning experience, for both sides when it’s across generations in my experience. I am trusted by my younger professional friends because I seem so much more progressive or to the left to their ear than what passes for a liberal Democrat among middle aged to older NC partisans. And I’m not partisan. But they’d learn a lot from listening to some of the people my age now on the right, a lot of suppressed history that drove those people there. It would be helpful when seeking solutions, problem solving, moving forward, keep us from recreating square wheels.

JD's avatar

Great article. Tangential comment: Substack’s automated voiceover doesn’t pronounce restack correctly. It sounded like rez hack. Who might we notify about this to get it fixed?

Chris's avatar

Interesting essays! Swamped with post-retreat work, so I can only offer scattered thoughts:

My sense is that the feasibility of trust but verify (when it really matters) correlates strongly with wealth...because the more resources you have, the milder the consequences of getting something wrong.

I marvel at the cognitive dissonance between "Trust the experts" and centuries of common law, adversarial legal systems predicated on the belief that ordinary citizens are capable (with the assistance of probing questions) of adjudicating between conflicting expert testimony. Seems like we lost the plot somewhere, and many of us now take the existence of competing claims of expertise as evidence that expertise itself is a fraud. More charitably, maybe those yard signs are...not ironic so much as perlocutionary: either an inside reference aimed at the like-minded or a deliberate provocation aimed at others. Which isn't to deny that it can be corrosive...

I'm dismayed to see Fauci's defenders and critics alike implicitly agreeing that Trump I's approach to COVID was even capable of yielding good policy. It's like we don't remember administrations that aspired to be more than a collection of sock puppets and scapegoats. A president picking one person to be the face of the federal government, an ad hoc role that exists entirely at the president's pleasure...then basking in reflected glory when the lone expert does something popular, and scapegoating them for everything that's unpopular... that's not leadership.

Setting those disparate thoughts aside, I agree on the most fundamental point of all. So much dysfunction flows from the conviction that other citizens are the country's greatest threat (and deserve to be defeated)...

Sam's avatar
Aug 13Edited

Those of us who are very pro-credentialed expertise - probably because they've done visible good for us in our own lives - can take small steps of understanding. I feel spooked by rallying around "Trust but verify," and breaking down what "verify" actually means is helping.

It doesn't meant doing our own "research" in the sense of doing a study, because we can't do that unless it's already our job. It doesn't mean "find a second person that affirms the same thing" because you can do that for anything - no useful signal.

I think it just means establishing a chain of trust, even if it's a short chain. I trust a given movie reviewer to give opinions that are honest and helpful to me. I trust a doctor because they have credentials and experience that have aligned with previous positive outcomes for me. I trust this link in the chain because it's connected to some small bit of my previous experience or someone else's experience. It can be a long chain, too. I trust that this is a good academic book because it's recommended by x, y, and z, scholars who wrote textbooks I was forced to read by professors who I trusted.

When dealing with someone who is skeptical of expertise that we find credible and think would be helpful, often we are the potential link of trust. We vouch for friends, for coworkers, for our dentist, all the time. Some of us vouch for our religion. I think there is probably even value in expressing that the broad medical consensus, such as it is, has done very good things for me and many other people, as long as we recognize that we are speaking about personal experience. It is reasonable for someone with different experience to have skepticism.

What's less reasonable and more pernicious is when positive assertions are tied to "I wouldn't put it past them." Just because they have the moral fiber to do so doesn't mean they have the ability or desire to do so, and it sure doesn't mean they did. Some conspiracist narratives eventually ask a person to choose between it and everything else that person thinks they know about science/history/government. One small thing people like me on team Boring Credentialed Authority can do is make sure that we aren't the ones forcing the choice. Yes, if the moon landing were fake, that would imply x, y, z, all the way down. But until you come to me and insist that I take action on overthrowing the government that faked the moon landing, I'm not going to say it's unacceptable that you doubt the authority on this one.

This of course is what made COVID so difficult. "Live and let live" is a public health policy choice that really does potentially impact people who do not make the same choice. So rather than accepting that it doesn't matter one way or the other, we have to try to keep the decisions from being totalizing of our view of a person.