34 Comments
User's avatar
BrainRotfront!'s avatar

I think Fauci is absolutely to blame. He totally leaned into his status as some sort of center-left cultural figure and vindicated for many the general "I believe in science" ethos to do so. The reality is that it's kind of hard to climb to the top of an organization as massive and influential as the CDC without being a politician first and a scientist second - and that's not inherently a criticism because something like his job during COVID was absolutely a dual scientific and political role.

I think it can simultaneously be true that a lot of the attacks on him are basically girded in nonsense insanity - and that there should be significant criticism leveled at him. I think it's clear that blame can be spread all around to a lot of people, but there's no way to actually view Fauci's COVID response as actually successful. Maybe due to the intransigeance of others sure, but a lot of that is also because his job was a partly political role, he not unreasonably played politics, but then he played it poorly

Michael Judge's avatar

Frankly, its very unfair to publish someone's diary. How could they NOT be embaressing. Very good post, Lauren, reinforcing that many things that may seem to be in opposition, can simultaneously be true.

Sam's avatar

I do not spend much time thinking about COVID or Fauci, likely because it all happened A. before my kid was old enough to be in school, and B. without any direct impact on my job. But I do have as vivid memories as anyone of the year 2020, and I wonder what, even in retrospect, people would have wanted from Fauci. What would the ideal political-scientific actor have done?

Some things I think people would include: Express more uncertainty (I remember uncertainty being the main impression I got from everyone in government but perhaps I was projecting). Encourage people to gauge appropriate precautions based on their own risk preference. Tell states to get schools open faster. Express more openness to musing about a lab leak.

I'm not sure how much any of this aside from school opening would have impacted most people's lives in that different a way, but I'm curious what people actually want him to have done.

BrainRotfront!'s avatar

His diaries are genuinely kind of...sad to read. Clearly not an "bad" guy in any way, but clearly flawed in a way humans typically are - and in a way that I don't think ended well for anyone.

"More than 1,100 pages long and dating from 2019 to 2022, Dr. Fauci’s diary reads like a black comedy of manners in which a 79-year-old social-climbing scientist becomes the face of the government’s response to a pandemic and then the toast of the town — the toast of this town. As the death toll rises, so too does the doctor’s status and self-regard. He falls in with a fast crowd and becomes consumed by his own image.

It’s like Thackeray’s Vanity Fair crossed with The Plague by Camus.

In entry after entry, he chronicles his glittering years on the Washington party circuit. He sips champagne at galas thrown in his honor and gets mobbed for selfies at sceney joints like Cafe Milano. Barbra Streisand calls and calls. Julia Roberts sends flowers. Billy Crystal, Elton John, Brad Pitt and Robert DeNiro are mentioned."

https://www.nytimes.com/2026/07/28/us/politics/fauci-diary-fame.html

Lauren Hall's avatar

I agree the journals are kind of sad as reported in the press, though I'd also say that I would absolutely hate for anyone to read my personal journals and it's very hard to know how many entries actually mention adulation given that there's at least a 1000 pages. Surely most of those deal with other things. He also might just think it's fun and kind of nuts that he's hobbnobbing with celebrities. But either way I think we both likely agree that being an egotist and a poor communicator at times does not justify a full-scale investigation of the kind he's facing.

BrainRotfront!'s avatar

I think "he was bad at his job when it mattered" and "people are insane for wanting him to die in jail for being bad at his job" can simultaneously be true.

George Nolan's avatar

I can see a case that could be made that there are influential figures in politics and media exacerbating things with the diary exposure and the grilling Fauci took at last Wednesday's Senate hearing, especially in our current times where politics and media are largely focused on fomenting anger and division between the masses with the current incentives there are in place in both mediums. While there are people that do genuinely want to seek answers to what the causes of the pandemic were considering the life-altering circumstances of it that impacted many and there were actually answers presented from both the diary and hearing, this sadly gets overshadowed from the embellishment Senate Republicans made in both instances between Rand Paul getting too cute with the aesthetics to the opening page of the diary when he posted it on social media and the senators not helping themselves with their exaggerated declarations and expressions that have sadly become the norm with the political theater of Congressional hearings.

But look under the hood and take some time to review the diary, there's plenty to scrutinize with it as Fauci was documenting enough about the media attention and social gatherings he attended while becoming the main face of the pandemic that he embellished going against the humble image he presented publicly as the head of a federal health agency and a good deal of what he wrote in it contradicts whatever he was saying publicly about matters such as COVID's origins, using his influence to sway politicians on precautionary measures, inflating numbers on the threat of the virus to the public, and censoring or putting pressure on those with differing perspectives of the pandemic. Some independent reporters have already been covering elements of the origins and handling of the pandemic over the past several years now. If you have time to dip your toes in and dabble into the particulars, you'll find more to learn about things than what many media outlets are covering. https://www.racket.news/p/after-fauci-debacle-our-idiot-press

Sam's avatar

This is an accurate presentation of what "science" is but I'm not sure it's a fair polemic against the beliefs of those inclined to say things like "trust the science".

I'll grant that some people have a sign with a dozen slogans on them, one of which is "I believe in science," who don't know or much care that "science is a process." But most people who pick that as a specific issue of concern know that science is an imperfect and iterative process. There aren't many modernist positivists out there these days. If I thought I found one, I'd assume I was actually dealing with a rationalist - a wild breed, but not one who thinks "science" is a fixed point.

If the objection is that "I believe in science" means very little beyond "I agree with Bacon that experiments should be repeatable," then fair enough. Again, I don't think that means that people who say it are necessarily naive about what science is. They intend the slogan to communicate "I have the epistemic humility not to believe I can come to better conclusions about scientific questions than a community of experts." That's not the same as being humble when proclaiming the slogan. In that regard, I'm very interested in the post about "trust the experts," because I think that's much closer to what "trust the science" people mean. I'll save further screeds about epistemic humility for that comment section.

Lauren Hall's avatar

My comparison group is admittedly my fellow academics in the social sciences and humanities, many of whom have the "I believe science is real" yard signs and who are absolutely comfortable politicizing science when its results doesn't conform to their political beliefs. I don't have any way to know what percentage of yard sign holders do the same thing, but I suspect it's a pretty large number.

None of this, of course, is to argue that the attacks on science from the right, including the current persecution of Fauci, are either justified or equivalent to the yard sign folks. But the yard sign folks are, I think, part of a larger problem whereby we politicize science, pretend we're not, and then open the door for the kind of deeply dangerous attacks the Trump administration is wielding against scientists from a variety of directions.

Frans's avatar

Great essay and comments by all. As an engineer I was lucky enough that politics did not enter the picture, and that of course was not the case with Covid. It quickly became almost all about politics, and that inevitably introduces an us versus them mentality, that the scientists then adopted too. Hence the silencing of respected scientists with different viewpoints. Fauci also succumbed to the adulation of celebrities and media, and this may have distracted him from being able to step back and admit that perhaps his views were not right. So much of this goes back to ( political) leaders not trusting that in general the majority of our population is smarter than given credit for and can accept other answers than "trust me, this is the right answer" and can accept uncertainty.

But just focusing on Fauci is besides an obsession from some politicians also a distraction from calling others to task who may have done similar harm especially to our school age children. Think of the heads of teachers unions who kept kids out of school way longer than necessary.

In all of this a true service to the public would have been an honest lessons learned exercise underwritten and endorsed by all the relevant leaders, without prosecutions or threats of jail, but that is too much to ask and just wishful thinking.

Sam's avatar

I have no special insight into what people with or without yard signs think, so your sense could well be more accurate than mine.

It's not that I think people using the slogan aren't politicizing science, sometimes even in bad faith. It's that I think they do, by and large, know that science isn't a fixed destination. I think the grass root science skeptic actually knows that, too.

I'm not sure how much better the conversation would be if it shifted from use of the term "science" to "best effort consensus drawn from a network of credentials, peer review, economic incentives, and time," but it would be more precise and draw out the points of conflict more directly.

James Goen's avatar

This is a good and fair response to Lauren's article and represents the humility around how to approach these conversations and to not simply reach for certainty but rather embrace the uncertainty that comes even from scientific inquiry.

From my vantage point, I think Lauren's main call out is the attitude and approach that simply saying "trust the science" is sufficient to end a conversation with someone who doesn't "trust the science." Using catch phrases as a means of simply winning a political argument or shutting down disagreement can be a form of bullying and manipulation that others the people that you one would hope people would be trying to persuade vice control.

I can sense a main point of this description is to try to preserve the humanity of the people we are in conversation with and to reintroduce some of the epistemic humility in conversation with people who may have a different view point.

There's a James Clear quote that I love, "We get better at what we practice, and everything we do is practice." This is an encouragement to me to practice more epistemic humility in conversations around disagreement to trust that the humility will be a better teacher of the people I am in conversation with than my assertion of my view point.

Lauren Hall's avatar

"I can sense a main point of this description is to try to preserve the humanity of the people we are in conversation with and to reintroduce some of the epistemic humility in conversation with people who may have a different view point."

Exactly.

Sam's avatar

I should actually respond to your prompts, too.

"Worse" or "always contextual and political" is a false dichotomy. Science has always been contextually dependent and directional rather than final, but it is also worse now. It's easier and more incentivized to widely promulgate absolute bunk, and the inclination to do so is more aligned with national and even global partisan alignments, encouraging people to entrench. Carpetbaggers have an impressive history of deception, but it has never been so profitable or durable.

I don't think it has many implications for most people doing the work of science. We do have a dire need of strong science communicators.

Lori's avatar

Whenever I hear anyone say it’s worse now, I wonder, worse for who? Many individuals in many groups always suffered what we consider “worse.” While I agree that we do have a dire need for strong communicators, including in science, I think it is naive to think it doesn’t have many implications for the people doing the work of science.

Sam's avatar
Jul 30Edited

If the implication is that, prior to "now," there was some group who was experiencing the firehouse information flow combined with globally aligned political interests creating partisan incentives for staying on message along a range of otherwise unrelated and independently contestable beliefs about the world, I'm curious to know who was already experiencing something similar. Broadened out, perhaps there have always been people more exposed to limited and manipulated information than others.

Well, insofar as scientists need to write grant proposals that people approving them like, it's fair to say that they are implicated in some concrete ways. But I think there are a lot of layers between the autoclave and the citizen with much more relevance to trust in expertise and experimentation, such as funding choice, communication, and regulation.

Edit: I should add that while my wife used to work in a lab, I'm not working with personal experience in a lab, making decisions with an eye toward public trustworthiness.

Lori's avatar

No, the implication is that “worse” always begs the question, worse for who, and of course, why. A certain self-centeredness and tunnel vision among the connected and powerful among us …I include myself in that assessment… tends to make us see things through the lens of access to the products and benefits of the process with blinders to exclude those who do not have that access.

There are actually people today who do not now and never have had access to the firehouse information flow of the internet nor information about with global political interests aligned or not, and thus have little to no sympathy for those responding to the partisan incentives for staying on message along a range of otherwise unrelated and independently contestable beliefs about the world.

Many of “us” genuinely don’t understand that. It breeds a kind of paternalism combined with a type of arrogant ignorance I’ve personally only found among my equally well educated colleagues.

Tom Williams's avatar

Great article and discussion. My one nitpick is with Lauren’s characterization of Fauci’s congressional non-testimony as a “prosecution.” It wasn’t; he can’t be prosecuted because Biden pardoned him. Which meant his repeated invocations of the 5th Amendment were pointless. And potentially legally problematic in the unlikely event that someone in Congress launches a long-shot attempt to cite him for contempt.

Lauren Hall's avatar

The term was, I think, “persecution.” The administration is doing plenty of damage to him without needing formal prosecution at this point.

Connie McClellan's avatar

There are plenty of problems with science, since it's an artifact of our culture and of the Enlightenment. Some interesting research paths don't get followed for years because scientists think they're impossible or irrational (The Light Eaters by Zoë Schlanger describes how botanists researching communication between plants were not taken seriously.) If a notion doesn't seem possible to known science, then it can languish ignored and unfunded. This is due to tendency of science to believe we already know it all.

Then, of course, there are all the stories about lack of medical data for women and non-white people.

I personally think our current culture is overly rational. There's this belief in absolute "science" on the one hand and social delusions on the other. Truth is an absolute, and only the humans alive right now have access to it. But between quantifiable "truth" and crazy social delusions are things like stories, metaphors, religion (OMG!), scripture, myth, and all the other ways humans have been finding value and meaning in the world. Don't throw out the baby with the bathwater.

Lauren Hall's avatar

Yes! I wish people wouldn't lump things into categories the way we do. It goes even further than human meaning, though that's a huge component. The current distinction between the medical model and the midwifery model for birth, for example, tends to force women into a false choice. The reality is that women and their babies have the outcomes when they can access the full range of options available and choose based on their unique circumstances. The same is true in oncology where there's growing recognition that patients need not just chemo but also "alternative" treatments at the same time. But when either side demonizes the other as irrational it reduces the options that people have and gives us worse outcomes.

Lisa Hermsen's avatar

As a rhetorical exercise, one might ask about the intent of a slogan as a communicative act. And ask about this particular slogan as one in a network of slogans appearing on buttons, bumperstickers, t-shirts, coffee mugs, and yardsigns. A slogan may or may not be recognized or recognizable as a slogan-- though most of us are able to identify the linguistic qualities.

Because these are "by rule" 5 words or less, they are not up to the task of framing a nuanced public debate.

Two short points, because it's rhetoric not philosophy. Slogans are unique? rhetorical devices. I would argue, as someone who loves my bird t-shirts, that the intent is not to present a complete political argument. My t-shirt most likely does not serve the purpose of laying out my understanding of the issues or offer evidence for my belief (not an argument), or offer any context for the value of holding this belief above others. And et.

This is why slogans are messy. They are appeals without arguments. The communicative act may simply be (not simple) to identify a very broad idea that is already shared among members of a community... Slogans have managed to do a lot of hard work for those who have needed to identify their community members.

Lauren is right to ask whether this slogan is doing good work at this moment. As I would ask, is it doing the hard work of identifying members of a shared community? Is it doing any work at all to express a shared value? Or has it become too messy to align across that larger network of slogans?

Slogans change too. This one may need to be edited for future prints.

I believe in science and I believe in rainbows and I believe that the birds are the experts. It is always already absolutely too early.

Lauren Hall's avatar

I think you're absolutely right. My worry about using slogans like this one is that they politicize and polarize spaces that are dangerous to polarize. I don't think people intend to do this. They're signaling their disapproval of terrible policies, signaling belonging to a particular group with particular views and values. None of that, by itself, is concerning. But given the dangers of political sorting and the tendency of public health in particular to be aligned with a particular political view, it sets up a vicious cycle that leads us to Fauci's position today. Not inevitably, but it increases the overall pressure in that direction.

I don't know what the answer is, but I know in my own rhetoric I've become very aware of and very cautious about signaling that might polarize critical institutions. The AAUP, on the other hand, has chosen the opposite this week (much to my chagrin).

Lisa Hermsen's avatar

I agree.

Slogans are devices that have intent, but may or may not work the way we intend. The slogan has turned into a rallying cry for this moment. It's truly fascinating and the scholarship over in Communication is actually interesting.

Science is political. It is not outside of funding and review. So do I now ask first, which science and from which lab and supported by which funding agency? Yes. And that. Should be on a bumpersticker. Do I want a diary or system of review lthat resembles the Royal Society? No.

Slogans sometimes do heavy lifting. This one cannot bear the weight.

JD's avatar

I agree that the current attacks on Fauci are excessive. But to describe Fauci’s lying (about mask usage, sponsoring GOF research and the possibility of a lab leak) as “imperfect” is a woefully inadequate description.

Lauren Hall's avatar

Imperfect might have been too weak, but I also recognize that public health officials are always caught between a rock and a hard place. Total transparency can lead to panics and deeply dangerous outcomes. Lack of transparency undermines faith in the system itself. I think Fauci made a number of ill-advised decisions and that's a major reason we should have had a non-partisan/bipartisan postmortem that created guidelines and guardrails for future pandemics. He was facing a relatively unprecedented situation without a rule book in place. He made a number of very dumb mistakes, but I *think* (though I don't know for sure) that he was acting in good faith. That doesn't excuse lying, but I don't think his intentions were malicious. All the more reason to make sure we avoid that kind of paternalistic error in the future and provide better guidance on how to navigate the fine line between transparency, misinformation and deceit when situations are in flux and information changes daily.

JD's avatar

I agree he was probably acting in good faith when he lied about mask usage. I understand that trade-off. But I struggle to find a good faith explanation for lying about GOF research and Covid origin theories.

Dave Porter's avatar

Wm Perry labels one of the final stages of cognitive development as "contextual relativism" and this aligns with Lauren's observations and arguments. However, Perry goes on to suggest the highest stages of development involve commitment despite an acknowledgement of ambiguity and uncertainty. The earliest stages of Perry's model could be characterized as premature commitment (i.e., commitment before an understanding of a chosen belief and the evidence supporting it and its alternatives.) From my experience, scientists hesitate to commit to anything other than the scientific method itself as a way of gaining understanding. It is far better to understand the things one does not believe in than to believe in things one does not understand. I think it was Carl Sagan who quipped extraordinary claims ((i.e., belief in apparent absurdities) require extraordinary evidence.

Lisa Hermsen's avatar

I didn't have this reference handy. I remember the "Darwin fish" parody of the traditional ichthys symbol. And the variations that showed up on cars everywhere at about the time I learned how to drive in the 1980s. The appearance of the robot fish and T-Rex fish may have pushed the symbol/slogan to its limits. There is no Darwinism. The reference I looked for and didn't find describes the Darwin fish as mockery, intimidation, rebuke. A finger pointing at anti-science, anti-intellectualism.

#I stand with science

is absolutely a sorting mechanism, but it fails once we all agree there is no such thing as a Science to stand by. I don't mean in the social study of science way, though also. What's being sorted is more complicated. Not infinitely so.

Glad I am not thinking much more on this. Let me know when the topic turns to Iowa and water!

Lori's avatar

You are a brave woman, Lauren, and that is much appreciated. I can tell you from experience that accurately pointing these things out can often have “both sides” assuming you are the enemy of their dimensionally challenged, opposing and limited positions. Occasionally, in some contexts, with some audiences, it can bring the sides together “against a common enemy.” In my experience that’s kind of a guy thing, or a woman thing when the woman in question wants to be one of the guys, but maybe it seems that way to me because I’m an old white woman long among old white guys who have or want power by virtue of expertise that is overstated to begin with. Looking forward to part two.

Robert Greenwood's avatar

Well presented. Thanks for a great read this morning.

forumposter123@protonmail.com's avatar

COVID restriction were so costly, immoral, and unconstitutional that I really put them in another category of pure unadulterated and unjustifiable evil. The proper fate of Fauci is that he should be tortured and executed.